Mathematics CONTINUITY OF THE SUM, DIFFERENCE , PRODUCT AND QUOTIENT OF TWO FUNCTIONS

Continuity

General Introduction :

After conceiving the notion of limits the next element which is taken into consideration is the continuity of
function. Qualitatively the graph of a function is said to be continuous at `x = a` if while travelling along the
graph of the function and in crossing over the point at `x = a` either from Left to Right or from Right to
Left one does not have to lift his pen .ln case one has to lift his pen the graph of the function is said to
have a break or discontinuous at `x = a`. Different type of situations which may come up at `x = a` along the
graph can be :




Figure (2) - (6) is discontinuous at `x = a` and in figure ( 1) f is continuous at `x = a`

Definition Of Continuity Of a Function :

A function `f(x)` is said to be continuous at `x = a`,

if `Lim_(x->a)f(x) =f(a)`

`=>Lim_(h->0) f (a-h)= Lim_(h->0)f(a+h)=f(a)=a` finite quantity.

i.e. `LHL` at `x = a = RHL` at `x = a` = value of `f(x)` at `x = a` finite quantity.

`text(Note:)`

`(i)` Continuity at `x = a => ` existence of limit at `x = a`, but not the converse.

`(ii)` Continuity at `x = a =>` `f` is well defined at `x = a`, but not the converse.

`(iii)` Discontinuity at `x=a` is meaningful to talk if in the immediate neighborhood of
`x = a`, i.e. the function has a graph in the immediate neighborhood of `x = a`, not necessarily at `x = a`.

`(iv)` Continuity is always talk in the domain of function and hence `f(x) =1/x-1 ,1/x, tan x` are all continuous
functions but if you want to talk of discontinuity then we can say `1/(x-1)` is discontinuous at `x=1, 1/x` is
discontinuous at `x = 0`.

Note that all rational functions are continuous. Because continuity is always talk in the domain of `f(x)`.

`(v)` Point function are continuous.
e.g. `sqrt (1-x) + sqrt (x-1) , sqrt (x) +sqrt (-x)`

`(vi)` Inverse of a discontinuous function can be continuous.

e.g. `f(x) = [tt( (1+x^2, text(if) x ne 0) , ( 0 , text(if) x=0) , (-(1+x^2) ,text(if) x ne 0) )` is discontinuous at `x = 0` but its inverse function

`f^(-1) (x) = [tt( ( sqrt(x-1) , text(if) x>1 ) ,(0, text(if) x=0) ,(sqrt (- (1+x)) , text(if) x <-1) )` which is a continuous function and its graph is as shown.


Continuity In An Interval :

`(a)` A function `f` is said to be continuous in `(a, b)` if `f` is continuous at each & every point `in (a. b)`.

`(b)` A function `f` is said to be continuous in a closed interval `[a , b]` if:

` quad quad quad quad quad quad quad(i) ``f` is continuous in the open interval `(a, b)` &

` quad quad quad quad quad quad quad(ii)` `f` is right continuous at ` a ` i.e., `Lim_(x->a^+) f(x) =f(a) =a` finite quantity .

` quad quad quad quad quad quad quad quad(iii) ` `f` is left continuous at ` b ` i.e., `Lim_(x->b^-) f(x) =f(b)=a` finite quantity.

Reasons Of Discontinuity :

A function can be discontinuous due to the following reasons.

`(i)` `Lim_(x->a) f(x)` does not exist (`f(a)` may or may not be defined)

i.e., `Lim_(h->0) f(a+h) ne Lim_(h->0) f(a-h)`

e.g. `f(x)= [x]` discontinuous at all integer points `f(x) = sgn x` discontinuous at `x =0`

`f(x) =x /(x-1)` discontinuous at `x = 1`.

`(ii)` `Lim_(x->a) f(x) ` exist but is not equal to `f(a)` i.e `Lim_(h->0) f(a+h) = Lim_(h->0) f(a-h) ne f(a)`.

EX. `f(x) = [ tt ( ( (1-x) tan ((pi x)/2) , text(if) x ne 1 ) , (pi/2 , text (if) x=1 ) )`

`Lim_(x->1) f(x) =Lim_(x->1) (1-x) tan ((pi x)/2) = Lim_(h->1) ( -h/(tan ( (pi h)/a )) ) = 2/pi`


`=> Lim_(x->1) f(x) ne f(1) => f(x)` is discontinuous at `x = 1`.


`(iii)` `f(a)` is not defined

e.g. `f(x) =1/(x-1)`

(iv) To understand explicitly the reasons of discontinuity. Consider the following graph of a function.

`quadquad quadquadquadquadquad(a)` `f` is continuous at `x = 0` and `x = 4`
`quadquadquadquadquadquadquad(b)` `f` is discontinuous at `x = 1` as limit does not exist
`quadquadquadquadquadquadquad(c)` `f` is discontinuous at `x = 2` as `f (2)` is not defined although limit exist.
`quadquadquadquadquadquadquad(d)` `f` is discontinuous at `x = 3` as `Lim_(x->3) f(x) ne f(3)`
`quadquadquadquadquadquadquad(e)` `f` is discontinuous at `x = 5` as neither the limit exist nor `f` is defined at `x = 5`.


`text(Note:)`

`(i)` Every polynomial function is continous at every point of the real line.
`f(x) =a_0x^n +a_1x^(n-1) +a_2x^(n-2) + ......+a_n AA x in R`

`(ii)` Every rational function is continuous at every point where its denominator is different from zero.

`(iii)` Logarithmic functions, exponential functions, trigonometric functions, inverse circular functions, and
modulus functions are continuous in their domain.

Types Of Discontinuity:

Removable Discontinuity:

Here `lim_(x->a) f(x)` necessarily exists, but is either not equal to `f(a)` or `f(a)` is not defined. In this case,
therefore it is possible to redefine the function in such a manner that `Lim_(x-.a) f(x) =f(a)` and thus making
the function continuous. These discontinuities can be further classified as

(A) Missing point discontinuity :

Here `Lim_(x->a) f(x)` exists. But `f(a)` is not defined.

(a) `f(x) =( ((x-1) (9-x^2) )/(x-1) ) x ne 1`

at `x = 1, f(1)` is not defined. Hence `f(x)` has missing point of discontinuity at `x = 1`.

(b) `f(x) =( (x^2 -4)/(x-2) ) x ne 2`

`f(2)` is not defined. Hence, `f(x)` has missing point of discontinuity at `x = 2`.

(c) `f(x) =(sin x)/x , x ne 0`
`f(0)` is not defined. `f(x)` has missing point of discontinuity at `x = 0`.

(B) Isolated point discontinuity :

Here `Lim_(x->a) f(x) ` exists, also `f(a)` is defined but `Lim_(x->a) f(x) ne f(a)`


(a) `f(x) = [x] + [-x] = [ tt ( (0, text(if) x in I) , (-1 , text(if) x notin I) )`

has isolated point of discontinuity at all integeral points.

(b) `f(x) = sgn (cos 2 x - 2 sin x + 3 ) =
sgn ( 2 ( 2 + sin x) ( 1 - sin x) )
= [ tt ( (0,text (if) x=2n pi + (pi/2)) , ( +1, text(if) x ne 2 n pi +(pi/2)) ) `

has an isolated point at `x =0` discontinuity as `x = 2 n pi + pi/2`

Non -Removable Discontinuity :

Here `Lim_(x->a) f(x)` does not exists and therefore it is not possible to redefine the function in any manner to
make it continuous. Such discontinuities can be further classified into 3 fold.

(a) Finite type (both limits finite and unequal)

(i) `Lim_(x->0) tan^(-1) (1/x)= [tt( (f(0^+) =pi/2) , ( f(0^-) = - pi/2) )` ; jump `= pi`

(ii) `Lim_(x->0) (|sin x |/x)= [tt( (f(0^+) =1) , ( f(0^-) = - 1) )` ; jump `= 2`

(iii) `Lim_(x->2) ( [x]/x) =[tt( (f(2^+) = 1) , ( f(2^-) = - 1/2) )` ; jump `= 1/2`

In this case non negative difference between the two limits is called the Jump of discontinuity. A function
having a finite number of jumps in a given interval `I` is called a Piece Wise Continuous or Sectionally
Continuous function in this interval.

(b) Infinite type (at least one of the two limit are infinity)

(i) `f(x) = (x/(1-x))` at `x=1 ,[tt( (f(1^+) =-oo) , ( f(1^-) = + oo) )`

(i) `f(x) = 2^(tanx)` at `x=pi/2 ,[tt( (f((pi/2)^+) =0) , ( f((pi/2)^-) = oo) )`

(i) `f(x) = (1/(x^2))` at `x=0 ,[tt( (f(0^+) =oo) , ( f(0^-) = oo) )`


(c) Oscillatory (limits oscillate between two finite quantities)

(i) ` tt ( (f(x) =sin( 1/x) ) ,( text (or)) ,( f(x) =cos (1/x)) ) ]` at `x=0` oscillates between `- 1` & `1`



(ii) `f(x) = [ 1+ 1/3 sin ( ln |x |)] ` at `x=0` oscillates between `0` & `1`.

Theorems On Continuity :

T -1 : Sum, difference, product and quotient of two continuous functions is always a continuous function.

However `h(x) = f(x) /g(x) ` is continuous at `x=a` only if `g(a) ne 0`

Following Important Notes Should Be Remembered :

(a) lf `f(x)` is continuous and `g (x)` is discontinuous then prove that `f(x) + g (x)` is a discontinuous function.

Proof: Let `f(x) + g(x)` is a continuous function.

so, `Lim_(x->a) ( f(x) = g(x) )= f(a) +g(a)` .........................................(1)

Also, `f(x)` is a continuous function `Lim_(x->a) f(x) + g(a)` ........................(2)

From `(1)` and `(2)`

`Lim_(x->a) g(x) = g (a) => g(x) ` is continuous at `x =a`.

But given `g(x)` is discontinuous at `x = a`.

Hence by contradiction `f(x) + g(x)` is discontinuous function.

(b) If `f(x)` is continuous & `g(x)` is discontinuous at `x = a` then the product function `phi (x) = f(x) * g(x)` is not necessarily be discontinuous at `x = a`. e.g.

`(i)` `f(x) = x ` & `g(x) = [tt ( (sin 1/x , x ne 0) ,(0, x=0) ) `

Then `f(x) * g(x) = { tt ( (x sin (1/x) , x ne 0) ,( 0, x =0) )` is continuous at `x = 0`.

`(ii)` `f(x) = cos ( (2x -1) /2) pi` is continuous at `x = 1` and `g(x) = [x]` and `[.]` denotes the greatest integer
functions is discontinuous at `x =1` but `f(x) *g(x)` is continuous at `x = 1`.

`Lim_(x -> 1^+) cos ( (2x-1)/2) pi*[x] =cos pi/2 * (1) =0`

`Lim_(x->1^+) cos ( (2x-1)/2) pi*[x] =cos (pi/2) * (0) = 0, f(1) =0 =>` continuous at `x = 1`.

(c) If `f(x)` and `g(x)` both are discontinuous at `x = a` then the product function ` phi (x) = f (x) *g(x)` is not necessarily be discontinuous at `x = a`. e.g.

`f(x) = - g(x) = [tt ( (1, x ge 0) , (-1 , x <0)) `

`:.` `f(x) g(x) =1 AA x in R` which is continuous function.

T-2 : Intermediate value theorem :

If `f` is continuous on `[a, b]` and `f (a) ne f (b)` then for any value `c in ( f( a ), f(b))` , there is at least one
number `x_0` in `(a, b)` for which `f(x_0) =c`


`text(NOTE :)`

`(1)` Continuity through the interval `[a, b]` is essential for the validity of this theorem.

`(2)` in figure-3 , `f(a)` and `f(b)` are of opposite sign but `f(x)` has no root in `(a, b)` as `f` is continuous.

T-3: Extreme Value Theorem:

If `f` is continuous on `[a, b]` then `f` takes on, a least value of `m` and a greatest value `M` on this interval.

Note :To see that continuity is necessary for the extreme value theorem to be true refer the graph
shown.

There is a discontinuity at `x =c` interval. The function
has a minimum value at the left end point `x = a` and `f`
has no maximum value.

Properties Of Function Continuous In `[a,b]` :

`(i)` If `a` function `f` is continuous on a closed interval `[a, b]` then it is bounded.

`(ii)` A continuous function whose domain is some closed interval must have its range also in closed interval.

`(iii)` If `f` is continuous and onto on `[a, b]` and is onto then `f^( - 1)`(from the range of `f` ) is also continuous.

`(iv)` If `f(a)` and `f(b)` possess opposite signs then `3` at least one solution of the equation `f(x) = 0` in the open
interval `(a, b)` provided `f` is continuous in `[a, b]`.

Continuity Of Special Types Of Functions :

Continuity of functions in which greatest integer function is involved:

`f(x) = [x]` is discontinuous when `x` is an integer.

Similarly, `f(x)= [g(x)]` is discontinuous when `g(x)` is an integer, but this is true only when `g(x)` is monotonic

`g(x)` is strictly increasing or strictly decreasing).

For example, `f(x) = [ sqrty x]` is discontinuous when `sqrt x` is an integer, as `sqrtx` is strictly increasing (monotonic function).

`f(x) = [x^2], x ge 0` is discontinuous when `x^2` is an integer, as `x^2` is strictly increasing for `x ge 0.`



Now consider, `f(x)= [sin x] , x in [0, 2pi]*g(x) = sin x` is not monotonic in `[0, 2pi]`.
Forth is type of function, points of discontinuity can determined easily by graphical methods. We can
note that at `x =(3pi)/2` , `sin x` takes m tegral value `-1` but at `x= (3pi)/2` , `f(x) = [sin x]` is continuous.

Continuity of functions is which signum function is involved :

We know that `f(x) = sgn (x)` is discontinuous at `x = 0`.
In general, `f(x) = sgn (g (x))` is discontinuous at `x = a` if `g(a) = 0`.

Continuity of functions involving limit `Lim_(n->oo) a^n` :

We know that `lim_(n->oo) a^n = { tt ( (0, 0 le a <1) ,(1, a=1) ,(oo , a > 1))`

Continuity Of Composite Functions :

If `f` is continuous at `x = a` & `g` is continuous at `x = f(a)` then the composite `g[f(x)] `is continuous at

`x =a` e.g., `f(x) = ( xsin x)/(x^2 +2)` & `g(x) = |x |` are continuous at `x = 0`. hence the composite

`(gof) (x) = |( x sin x)/(x^2+2) |` will also be continuous at `x =0`.

 
SiteLock